October Road -- who is sams father?

Okay here is what I think --

I think that it is Eddie. I think that in the last episode that is why he didn't want to open up best friend windows with nick until he knew the truth. I don't think that Eddie would keep it from Nick if Nick really was the father (because eddie knows who is) but he would hide it to protect nick. I could be wrong about eddie being the dad but I really don't think that nick is.. which sucks like crazy because I want him to be SO bad.

Ugh I think Eddie. Which is unfortunate because I just love Nick!!!

What if it's Nick's brother? (cant remember his name) That would explain why Nick's dad made that comment about Sam having Nick's mother's eyes. And the whole peanut allergy thing.
Probably not, but it IS a scenario I myself have considered. I care waaaaaay too much about tv shows! lol! Report It

I wanna know too!!! I don't think it's that Jasper guy or Eddie.... I think it may be Nick, but they don't want him to butt into there lives..

I still think that it's Nick!! If it was really Eddie, he's been there the whole time and NIck was gone, if Eddie really was the father, then why was he never a part of Sam's life?! That just doesn't make sense. The other guy....the one from out of town whos name has blanked at the second....yeah, Hannah definitly made him up.