SAW QUESTi0N?

i saw all 4 so far. im confused as to whether amanda young was in on the whole saw 2 thing with her being in that house. did he like force her into it. or was she already given a antidote? thanks

No she didn't already have the antidote. Jigsaw explained to her that before she could fully understand her work she had to understand what the people went through and he also needed to see how far she would go to save her own life, because if she wouldn't do anything for her life then she would be a hypocrite to the people she was trying to save.

From the very start of Saw 2 when they were in the house, she was trying to tell everyone to listen to his rules and they would all make it out. She told everyone he was trying to help them but of course they didn't listen. She was in on it, but she also had to make it through on her own before she could fully become Jigsaws apprentice.

He was testing her the entire three movies to see if she was the one to continue his work. When she failed her test in the third one by shotting the dudes wife, Jigsaw told her she had lost the game and she got killed. Also he knew the the people she had tried to save had no possible way to escape, how she rigged them up they were going to die no matter what they did and thats not what Jigsaw wanted to do.

she was forced into it because she cut herself and did drugs.

She was in it all from the first Saw.

She wasen't forced, she looked at John like a father, she wanted to help him, she claimed he helped her change her life, and she adored him for that.
She was already given an antidote, if she didn't then she was given one immediatley after.

Yes, she was in on it the whole time.

Did you hear after? While she was talking to Matthews?
When Jigsaw dies, i will continue his work, i will be the new Jigsaw.
Why would she say that? if Jigsaw did die before her, she wouldn't be forced then.


T.M.

She went in to see the whole thing playout.She was not being challengeda,dn she already had the antidote.

Actually she was a victim in the first Saw. Since she survived the game and he was dying, he needed someone to take over after he died, so he more or less talked her into it. He turned out to be sorta like a father figure to her i think. She says on the 2nd. one that he became her father. In my opinion she had to be a little off to begin with to do something like that, especially since she went through the same thing herself. But yea , she was in on the whole thing in the 2nd one.She's the one that got the boy out and took him to Jigsaw to be put in the safe!

in saw 3 it tells about everything that happens before the house thing so she pretty much had to be in but was not forced because she had already been working for him.