Skinny / Fat standard?

I have 2 friends,both females. Call em B & C.

B has a curvy body. Seriously, not like all these "fat women in denial calling theirselves curvy-curvy" but her shape really is curvy. She keeps trying to lose weight, but she's naturally chunky, so she has to work out extra hard than others do.
She's 5'6 - 60 kg (around 125-130 lbs). IS THAT FAT?

C has standard type of body. Very skinny in my opinion. Her shape doesn't have much curves. She's 5'7 - 110lbs.
She's not trying to lose weight but it's like she's very scared that if she gain just 1 kg it'll be the end of the world. She counts calories to the details (its annoying when I got out to eat with her), she worries about her portion and everything!


So tell me from YOUR point of view,
is B too fat? is C too skinny?

And I know it's inapropriate to ask,but if you dont mind I wanna know your height and weight. Like a survey.
I just want both of them to see all your answers, hopefully it can stop B from torturing herself and C to stop concerning about gaining weight.
Thanks

Dude I'm not worried how they look like!
I want THEM to stop worrying how they look! B's hot, alot of guys including my friends have asked her out, but shes still insecure about her looks! I want her to wake up when I show her all your answers, C too!

so dont judge me before you know me

In my opinion, C is a little bit too skinny. You can take her to fast food restaurants every now and then so she can gain few pounds :]p
But B sounds fine.
But if she wants to lose a little weight, she may, well you can't forbid her. You're her friend,so you're the one who should be there IF she HAS lost that bit of weight and she wants to keep pursuing being boney like C.
So as a friend, support what your friends are doing but don't let them go to far :)

I'm B's height and weight, do YOU think I should lose some weight?

They are both good weights
B may be slightly larger, but she is not fat.
C is like model thin and shouldnt be worried if she gains some weight

im 5'3 and 110 pounds

Get a life. If they were your friends, why would you care what they look like.

it matters wat is on the inside not the outside!!!!!!

c is too skinny.

B. is not to fat.
C. is to skinny

OMG R U SERIOUS! they're both fine! and tell C to stop freaking out! they are not to fat or skinny!

5'6 130, 14 years, and look great! *i've got thick thighs*

I think that B is in good shape;
I'm worried about C.
She sounds pretty skinny.

B is fine, 60 kilos is nothing & C needs to eat, too skinny.

Im a guy 6ft, 210lbs or 95 kilos

edit someone is bored, has given everyone a thumbs down lol

b isnt that "chunky" for her height thats just alitte over
maybe shes muscular but u would kno that

but people like C annoy the **** outta me i would slap some sense into her.

im 5'0 short yeah -.-
97 lbs.
but athletic so alot of muscle

B-does not sound fat at all
C- sounds really too skinny
I'm 5'4" 117 to 120

And people tell me how skinny I am

I am 5'3", and 170 pounds. But because I am part muscle weight, I am average instead of extra meaty.

I am darnest straight lucky I can still do a lot of shopping that's not plus size.

But I am suppose to be more like 110-115 myself as I am small-boned.

I plan to lose, but I'm doing it to be more healthy, not because of physical appearance. I'll done a bikini and not be self-conscious. People should care about my personality, not my looks!

Well i think B is a great siz. curvy woman are great!

C isnt wrong to want to portion her meals and count calories but i becomes a problem when she stops eating. she is ( in my opinion ) to skinny. about 10 pounds to gain would suit her good.

So, B is good where she is at and C is too skinny.

Im a Male and i weigh 150 and im about 5'6.

tell um to stfu


and stop being doosh bags


tell um to live live while they got it




who care what u look like

neither B or C is fat, i think there fine but C needs to gain muscel she sounds a little boney 5'7 and 110lbs, doesn't seem very appealin, I'm 5'4 and 124 and i have to watch what i eat and exercise cause i gain weight pretty quick. but your friends are neither fat and if B need to also gain muscel rather than tryin to lose weight. hope this helps:)

Most women worry about their weight so no statistic is going to help them..accept it..They need to find their"happy weight"..not someone else's..Tell them to stick to a weight that feels comfortable for them

B is a normal weight
C is way to skinny

Well I'm not going to tell you my weight. But I do believe that If you are happy with yourself and are healthy than you shouldn't worry what others think.

how old are they i know I'm not fat and i way about bs weight
and the other one just hasn't matured all the way yet





(shape doesn't matter to start with)

I would say that each person has their own weight that they need to be healthy and happy. What one person thinks is "right" or "skinny" isn't always what is the best. I think personally that B has a normal body size for this day and age...from the sounds of it "C" is definately too skinny. I am a big framed girl and at 18 I was 5'7" and 175 lbs. I thought that I was really fat, but now that I am 240 lbs. I really know that before I was just healthy and now am unhealthy and yes fat...

im wat u call fat and i denial , even tho i would personally call myself curvy. i think the standard shape is curvy. women were have hips and boobs and an *** 4 a reason and all those skiiny ppl are just unfemale looking

Being 5'6 and weighing 125-130 pounds is NOT fat, not even "slightly larger" that's how tall I am and how much I weigh and I've never thought myself to be slightly overweight nor has anyone else ever implied so. The fact that some of you people think that is "larger" disgusts me. God forbid someone have breasts and slight booty. I'm sick of this "pre-pubescent boy" trend, a body where ones ribs stick out further than their chest and that has a concave a*s*s is not sexy, nor has it ever been, nor will it ever be. Ask any fella. But really, does anyone know since when looking like your 12 year old brother has been thought to be appealing? And...who cares what your friends weigh, they're your friends and that's all that matters so **** it.