Timbaland... better producer or performer?

i say producer

Producer, people forget some of the hottest beats of the last 10 years were his,
Raise Up by Petey Pablo
I'm So Fly- Lloyd Banks
Put You on the Game- The Game
Roll Out- Ludacris
Big Pimpin'- Jay-Z
Pony-Genuwine

The guy is a hit machine, he only performs because he can produce

producer Report It

neither he sucks

ya me too

Yes he is wonderful at producing! I love that new song "apologize" that he produced.

producer

producer..his song by one republic was aweseom

producer... but he can perform good too so both!

producer.....definetely. He tries too hard to perform

producer

good producer, horrible performer

Producer... he comes up with great beats and interesting ideas. He's an OK performer, but he's not particularly charismatic or magnetic on stage.

He's good at both.But i would have to say proforming...

producer

I think he has some awesome beats, but his own songs tend to be a little stupid lyrically. And performing he is a little boring.

producer - but he can perform when he wants to.

Producer...Some people need to stay behind the scenes. Now, Missy on the other hand, can do anything!

Producer... But he needs to stop stealing his artists' thunder. Apologize was by One Republic only - so why is Timbaland considered the "artist"?

I love timbaland in both i dont know what the point is of having to choose between the two anyway.

Both! Hes the ****. Have you heard any of his older songs with Magoo.. they were the **** and inspired a lot of greats like missy e, aaliyah, genuwine.

Producer By Far

he is a better producer but he does both of them really well. if you really like him you can tell a timberland song just from the beat

producer by far, people dont realize most famous hip-hop songs use his beats, but he is a bad singer himself.