Who do you think deserved to be in the final more Beverley or Nikki? Why?

Personally I think Beverley, not only was she a great singer but she also came across as a nice, decent person, unlike Nikki who came across as arrogant and in subsequent interviews slightly mad!

BEVERLEY
she was so humble! nikki turned so arogant
and cocky about how good she was
and then all the selfish storys she sold to the newspapers
AWFUL

beverley should have been in that final
so did nikki but i prefer beverley

shoulda been
nikki
bev
and rhydian.. of course!

I think Beverly just because I liked her more than Nikki, I thought it was unfair how she left.

Nikki definitely! Same Difference shouldn't be there at all!

Nikki because she was the only one out of ALL of them who was consistently GOOD. She was probably kicked off as she has a husband and young family, every other winner has been unattached and without commitments and, therefore nothing to stand in their way. As I have said before I believe the winner is chosen at the start of the live shows! XFactor is fake

Niki...she has a great voice, but i think she may be a little bit old to be a pop star....mind you..tina turner and all the other mature diva's did it..so why not her...Rhydian to win....

I prefered Beverley to Nikki...just felt she had the better voice........but we all know Rhydian is gonna win.!!...w00t w00t.....lol

Beaverly because she had more potential and she has a better singing voice I was so annoyed how she got voted off instead of STUPID Hope! Nikki was ok though.

Beverley hard working and better voice in my opinion.

Both really had the potential to reach the final, with regards to their voices, however, we all know the X-Factor is not all about the best singer!!!!!
The best singer is Rhydian, by a mile, but that doesn't mean he's going to win!!!!!

nikki because she can cook w00t w00t.

Both of them should have been in the final.

Well I think they both should. The final three should have been Rhydian, Beverley and Niki because they are the only ones with any talent. Difficult to choose between Niki and Beverley because they are about equal. Niki was on Lorraine Kelly with Chico and Brenda from last year and Chico and Brenda both said that they had plenty of work and you didn't need to win it or be in the final to make a name for yourself. Niki said she already had offers too.

nik

nikki

yes i do think niki or bev should be in the final they were great singers i do under stand why they never got through with age and all and where they would sit in the market but i wanted either one to be there

Definately Bev ~ After everything that has happened since Nikki came out, i think that Nikki being in the final, might have pushed her over the edge mentally!!

Bev was a genuinely nice lady, with a great heart and voice!

I hope that we hear from her soon...................

Beverly, as her voice was better. Tough q whipass, performance wise Bev was faultless all the way thru, but Niki had a couple of dodgy weeks.

neither, cause all you ever heard out of them was a sob story of why they should be there.

I liked them both personally but preferred Niki as i did think she had the better voice.
I sure don't want Same Diference to win! And Leon (is that his name?) is just a recycled Ray Quinn!

bev was robbed sharon let her down big time