Poll : rhydian v leon?

who had the most talent ?

Rhydian!!!!!!!!!!!

Leon sings flat and hasn't enough confidence.

and Rydian isn't 'up himself' at all. He's a nice bloke and he's full of talent. I hope he manages to recover from this and get a recording contract and a good career.

Rhydian.

rydian had more talent but lets face it he was sooo up himself

Different types of singer, both great in their field. The final tune suited Leon and the public voted fairly.

Just as writing on a blackboard with cheese doesnt work, nor does a four chalk pizza ....

Both very talented but Rydians voice didn't suit pop, id go for Rydian though

Rhydian

Leon

They're both as good.....as amateurs who need someone to back them!

I just knew that Rhydian was being stitched up by the show from speaking to my Aunt and knowing how good she is as a trained opera singer. It's such a difficult skill that I knew Rhydian was heading for a fall. But, as I said before, the producers don't care, Catherine Jenkins had agreed to go on the show!! Ratings, ratings, ratings. He didn't stand a chance.

Whereas Leon faired better because being blunt, Kylie is crap!. She's a pop icon but as a live crooner she sucks!!! But, yet again, if you can get Kylie to perform on your show, screw the contestants!

I hope Leon and Rhydian go on to further success and I hope that Same Difference............enjoy the sea air at the end of the pier in summer season.

Leon and Rhydian wouldn't sell singers

Well since you're a Rydian fan, I hardly see any point in saying Leon because you'll just looking to get people to agree with you. So to answer your questions. whose the more likly person I'm more likley to go for is Leon because he is young, has the voice I like and I don't like Oprea.

Both are very good! Ryidain is a opera singer and Leon is pop so they're both got talent!

At the moment i think Rhydian - but give Leon time, and his talent will come through...
Put it this way - Rhydian couldn't do what Leon does - and Leon couldn't do what Rhydian does.
Tonight Leon raised his game, so it all depends on what type of music you like. I think Leon has a great voice - but Rhydian has great stage presence, but he couldn't really hold his own with Katherine Jenkins, he was drowned out a bit, don't you think -- also, Leon's only 18, he's hardly found himself yet

Rhydian!!

Rhydian by a mile

on the night leon

Rhydian his talent far outshines Leon`s. Again in these programmes it is not the best that wins....

Leon.

Rhydian!

But have to admit having a tear in my eye when Leon won, he was so shocked bless him.

Rhydian, sadly he got all the songs that didn't show his true talent

Rhydian no contest.

Rhydian is more talented

The best singer won, the best voice lost.

Actually ... although he was over-hyped .. I would say RYHDIAN...


dR bad
i'm surprised LEON was still there on the night.. he should have gone weeks ago

Obviously Rhydian Bex. I only caught the last 30 mins of the final because I was out but Rhydian didn't fail to move me emotionally with his singing - he is phenomonal. Leon is ok but doesn't have the Xfactor but he has looks and the young girlies were voting for him in droves as was Scotland. It was really not a talent contest but a looks and a Scotland v Wales contest. Gutted Rhydian didn't win but I think Leon will disappear into oblivion next year whereas Rhydian will shine. Hope so. xx

Rhydian.

It's unfair to say one is more talented than the other, you can't compare operatic style next to swing/jazz style. Those styles are so different that you can't pick common points from it.

Rhydian was great at the operatic stuff, absolutely amazing voice, but this meant he was never gonna be seen as mainstream.

Leon had a lot of warmth in his voice which you expect from jazz/swing, and this type of music is far more mainstream at the moment than it was even a couple of years ago.

Either way they are both really talented in their own genre, and I hope they will both have a long career ahead of them.

2 styles 2 winners poles apart in the in the music world.

Rhydian

RHYDIAN!!!

They both have a lot of talent and in different ways, No one could have predicted who would have won knowing for a fact that they would be right, they are both good singers in there own ways and they will go far. Good luck to them both!

theres no point in asking this question!!!

RHYDIAN 100%

Lol all I have to say is Rhydian...I can't even give an explanation he was robbed,I even voted I wanted him to win that badly.