Who sung the winners song better ?

leon or rhydian ?

Rhydian sang it by far. I still say Rhydian has been robbed of winning X Factor.

Rhydian, the song was shite, but I would have bought Rhydians version of it because it was full of emotion!

I think they were both good. It's not really a good song for a bloke really though is it. I hope someone picks Rhydian up, he's got a great voice and he really deserves the chance.

i think they both sang it equally well, however i prefered leons version. his voice is more appealing to me, it is a softer more natural and soulful. rhydians is too bold and operatic for me. i honestly believe his duet with kylie was far better than rhydians too. his voice did not quite gel properly with katherines.

Obviously both different - but i thought they were both good - i thought Leon raised it a little more than Rhyds did - and i love the song...

Neither Leon or Rhydian compare to Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey,so I would have to say none of them...maybe if Leona Lewis had a crack at this song maybe it would sound a lot better than Leon's and Rhydian's versions.

RHYDS!

Why ask????????????

I think leon sang it better, there seemed to be more emotion and effort.
each to their own tho! lol

Oh of course rydian sang it better. Rydain is always better at everything. He was brilliant the week he sang pink. He's been brilliant all the way though! Leon is shite and anyone who votes him should go to hell ( this is all said in sarcasm, as you Becky will know already) I thought Leon sang it better but hey I'm a scot, scots votes are all shite (sarcasm again)

RHYDIAN!!!!!!!!!!!

Bring back Rhydian!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Leon is cr@p!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He can't sing and he as zero personality!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LEON LEON LEON

I have to be honest thought Leon pulled it off better however it is not number one christmas song in my book.

Well neither of them are on a winning wicket with that shite song are they but Rhydian's version was slightly better!

Rhydian. Because he put some feeling into it. Leon always looks very apologetic.

two different styles Leon's was like a sing song down the local and rhydians was like a yuppies ball.if you know what i mean peeps.

I preferred Leon's version better, although Rhydian sang it well. I don't think it's particularly who sang it better, it wasn't a strong song to start with, so once they started playing around with the arrangement for each person they made it difficult to compare performances.

Rhydian, I was all signed into i tunes to buy it, but then when Leon won, I signed off itunes and got really quite angry.

Leon did - it suited his voice better than it did Rhydian's.

Rhydian most definately!!!

the song wasnt good but he made is reali good and full of emotion!!

u rock Rhyd!!

To be honest I wasn't to impressed with this years song,I mean last year "A moment like This" just had it and the same when Shayne ward did "That's my goal" the year before,but despite all that,I still think Rhydian perormed it better.