Can you tell me whether I am a good singer or not?

here is a clip of me singing:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=7UiKhLDYXQo

no,i cant tell

Although i think you can sing, i don't think this song suits you. Your voice is more of a punk rock type and i think you would do good singing some of songs like green day and ect. You want to sing songs that you can tune your voice with, try singing somthing like greendays songs and ask yahoo, I bet you will defenitely get some good replies, most defenitley!

I think you sounded great especially with singing with only a piano to accompany you.

You can carry pitch, but you shouldn't be doing Evanescence songs. You should practice being a Linkin Park or Dan Fogelberg type.

As people have mentioned before, Evanescence doesn't really suit you. Amy Lee has an extremely powerful voice and has quite a presence. If you want to try to sing like her, you're going to need to put quite a bit more volume and emotion into your singing. You definitely have potential, you just need to really put your heart into singing.

You can sing, but as everyone else has said, evanessance doesn't suit you, you should listen to wat everyone else has said, punk rock suits you, Try Foo Fighters, Tired of you, i think youd be good at that.

you are good but when you sing don't put 'R's on the end of your words :)