Kate/ Sonny/Carly????

Who is mad about that? Why didn't they tell Carly? I want her to know so bad that Kate was his first and last love!!!!!!!!!! grrrrrrrrrrr

Yeah, I know Sonny was honorable. But, what made me mad was that Carly left thinking that she was right, but she's not.

I know I was dying for him to tell her that she knew him way better than she ever could! But, NOOOO!!! I can't wait, if I were Kate I think I would spill it just to tick her off.

I think it was honorable of Sonny to continue to keep Kate's secret. Carly doesn't have to know everything.

Why should everyone know about Kate? Carly should just stew in her jealousy for a while longer. Times like these tho always bring Sonny and Carly back together. It will be interesting to see what happens now. Carly can do what ever she wants but the men in her life must only have her or she throws a huge temper tantrum like a spoiled brat.

carly doesnt need to know about sonny and kates past but it would have been nice to see him tell her how it is

They should have told her, that way she would understand better. But of course Carly got to leave thinking she was right.

Why does Carly care about who Sonny loves anyway?! She's married to Jax...

Carly's mad because she thought that Sonny would never love anyone again but her and that upsets her ego.

Carly is just plain weird because anytime sunny and her are together, she just pulls away and divorces him, but anytime sunny is even five feet next to a girl, her head looks like a volcano ready to erupt. Yes I am mad that they didn't tell Carly that Kate and him were lovers before, but then again Carly would do something so dramatically that it would change every ones lives and I would love to see Carly just boil with jealousy but i didn't write the script.

I really like Sonny and Carly together, but I think he wanted to keep it from her because Kate has trust in him. He loves Kate, and he had to move on because Carly is married to Jax.

who cares what carly thinks!!!! cant stand her self righteous, jason is my best friend, sonny is still my business..... GO KATE!!! btw, i dont care for her either, but carly need to mind her business!!!

Yeah, but Carly has a big mouth, and then Kate's secret would be out and her image would basically be trashed. It would be awesome though to see the look on Carly's face if she found out the truth. Like already said, she thinks she's right and we all know she's not.

I wish they would have told Carly. I would have loved to see her face. I like Carly because of her loyalty but I also think she is the biggest hypocrite on the show.

They didn't tell Carly because, as much as I like her, she is a loud mouth. Kate is not ready for the world to know that she is from Benson Hearst. Anyways, it isn't any of Carly's business since she is married to Jax, even if he is dead.