I thought i'd make it through without crying this ep.....?

until nicholas grabed the gun and was talking about it not working without her. and that song came on. what was the name of it? and who grabbed carly - coop or johnny?

i do think it was johnny becausee when lulu asked how he had cut his hand he had taken off the band aid so i do think it was him who grabbed carly and but a string around he neck and i do think it was johnny who killed emily

That was just so sad, and if he does commit suicide, it might be a daytime first. I also loved that song, I wish I could help. I don't know who grabbed Carly, but they wrapped a cord around her neck.

i don't think it was johnny that grabbed carly cause johnny has that bandaid wrapped around his hand, this person didn't.

I just gave up on the Nicholas-Emily saga ages ago....I doesn't bother me...I'm waiting until they tell Monica...she just lost her husband, now her daughter???? OH, that could be sad!!

I think It was Trevor... But i could be wrong. Nikolas Should have gotten help when he first started having these episodes...

I couldn't make it witout crying either. If that boy doesn't win the emmy next year, that's just wrong! I think maybe trevor grabbed her. I wasn't paying much attention to the music, I was crying too hard!

I doubt think Nicholas will commit suicide. "Emily" will speak to him and tell him to live for her and Spencer. Carly's first instinct was probably right,it was and is Coop. Making it Johnny is just too easy. And two maniacs in one family?

It was awful.. but the song was beautiful...does anyone who sings it?